With this article I hope to provide a Reasoned objection to Rationality Rules recent videos and statements from the YouTube channel "Rationality Rules" .
I don't understand "Sexual identity and preference are personal, psychological, and based primarily on gender". It seems confusing based on your 2 first definitions to mix up sex and gender like that. Should either be gender identity or the simplest definition of gender would be "a synonym for sex". Though I wouldn't agree with either version.
I agree with your last sentence "There are as many versions as there are people who have thought about it." And I am one of them ah ! Though not all opinions are equally valid, like I said in my post, there are objective truths and I can't take seriously those who deny them.
https://kaiserbasileus.substack.com/p/to-grok-sex-and-gender
I somewhat disagree with your definitions.
Here, I wrote a concise post on this :
https://curiousphilosophy.substack.com/p/sex-and-gender-very-quickly
I don't understand "Sexual identity and preference are personal, psychological, and based primarily on gender". It seems confusing based on your 2 first definitions to mix up sex and gender like that. Should either be gender identity or the simplest definition of gender would be "a synonym for sex". Though I wouldn't agree with either version.
I agree with your last sentence "There are as many versions as there are people who have thought about it." And I am one of them ah ! Though not all opinions are equally valid, like I said in my post, there are objective truths and I can't take seriously those who deny them.
sex - biology
gender - social, based on biology
related identities - individual, based on both biology and society
:p